Going to add some learnings here just for anyone else struggling with this print on an older printer. I'll start by saying the model has been updated and things print much better!!
My Ender 3 still couldn't quite keep up though even with the fix. I ended up slicing via Orca and using the classic and arachne Wall Generator options and viewing the preview I could still see the seams being added on some of the tight/small areas. The model printed using the Classic Wall Generator setting did give me fewer seams and better results, especially in regards to random gaps generated in the pattern. I do believe I could have messed with some more settings to maybe have eventually gotten a smooth print in the end, but honestly just printing this on a Bambu labs printer solved the gaps or over extrusions. I included a photo of the preview of a slice path as well where you can see that Orca is trying to fill in space on the Ender printer with a straight line which leads to extrusions in that area of the print. I'm calling my exploration here, but for those experiencing this issue, I hope this is a useful start to attempting to get a smoother print on an older printer!
Hi,
Thank you for this great design.
I was wondering if the highlighted connector/clip part (shown in the attached image) is included as a separate STL file. I couldn’t find a printable file for this specific piece.
Could you please let me know if the file exists or if it will be added?
Thanks in advance!Hi,
Thank you for this great design.
I was wondering if the highlighted connector/clip part (shown in the attached image) is included as a separate STL file. I couldn’t find a printable file for this specific piece.
Could you please let me know if the file exists or if it will be added?
Thanks in advance!
In your pictures and videos the tray does not have a dovetail, i think the dovetail messes with the mechanism and it is the only option in the files i get to download
In the description above it says that the outer pots and drip trays print upside down - but the file loads them up right - are we meant to flip it over in the slicer before printing?
That's what I did. I think the design, when it's built, is upright, and so it is assigned that orientation in the XYZ environment. So when you import into the slicer software, it inserts in that orientation. In this case, it prints better if you flip them. I suppose someone could design in CAD for optimal print orientation, but personally, that would be too much mental geometry gymnastics. Can you also reassign the orientation afterwards? anyone?
Print issues on the dome at the same location on both he small and the large. Looking at the STL, the model changes rib shapes. Does anyone else have this issue?
Coming back to edit my comment. I was able to download the new files finally (size changed), and see that the geometry changed. Slicing in Cura there's still a large amount of additional seams added in this area. Slicing in Orca seems to minimize those but they do still occur. Working on a print to see how the new model works out
On the lower curved part of the large trays, OrcaSlicer generates a perfectly smooth outer perimeter first, but then it goes back and adds many tiny extrusion “dots” all around the circumference on certain layers. In preview these appear as small isolated segments on top of the perimeter, and on the print they show up as bumps/marks around the surface.
Have you run into this when slicing the large trays yourself?
Do you have a version of the inner pots that have no holes? I have been beating myself up in the slicer trying to fill them. my wife has a plant that does not need draining. Thanks
🔴 The small version is that the groove mount extends into the bottom piece, so you cannot twist off the water catchment system unless you take the whole thing off the rail. This is a BAD design. Please design it so dovetail slot extends above the top of the main planter piece rather than into the lower bowl.
I love this design but pretty disappointing that the Dovetail Attachment for the rail is a separate download. Everything that is shown, should be included in the download that makes this design function. You have to use one of your downloads to complete the model.
Can anyone help me? I have a Chromebook and want to print out these files but Bambu Studio is not available for Chromebook. I tried following prompts on how to set it up through linux but I keep getting errors when I am loading Bambu Studio. Is there another program that can be run through the Chromebook OS that works with an A1 mini? Thanks!
This is a nice print. Classy shape, and the large is a good size. Two issues though.
The small version is that the groove mount extends into the bottom piece, so you cannot twist off the water catchment system unless you take the whole thing off the rail. Please design it so dovetail slot extends above the top of the main planter piece rather than into the lower bowl.
Also please inluce the rail mount and wedge so this is a stand alone purchase.
I think it's a very nice design and the printing took a long time but it's perfect.
My only request would be to have a pot as big as the largest one in The Rail v2. Once I got used to that size, this one seems small. Would that be possible?
Thank you very much.
Hi, I have printed everything with no issue. However, I don't seem to have the stl for the part that slides onto the dowel rods to connect the actual planter. Is that a separate download?
The "Ira for the Rail" fail seems to be faulty as it cannot be opened with any slicer tool. Ultimaker and Anycubic slicer said there are no contents in the file provided
As the creator did not respond for 11 days I had to purchase another set to be able to use this set as advertised. The print is good. The support from the creator disappointing.
These are just the pots. The mounting pieces are separate parts. They are in the Rail System download that can be accessed at the top of the product description for these planters.
This is a very nice looking model. I think it looks nicer than the original, but unfortunately I'm finding out that it's an insanely long print time. I'll be finishing one set and then probably not making another.
Thanks! Yes, designs that feature this fluted pattern tend to take longer to print because it's a lot of extra movement. Worth it in my opinion but I am planning on making some alternate patterns for this shape that should cut down on print time!
Discussions — The Rail - Ira Planter
Love it!
I'm almost certain it's this one here: https://than.gs/m/1145814
Came here to raise the same concern! @LoftedGoods
In the description above it says that the outer pots and drip trays print upside down - but the file loads them up right - are we meant to flip it over in the slicer before printing?
That's what I did. I think the design, when it's built, is upright, and so it is assigned that orientation in the XYZ environment. So when you import into the slicer software, it inserts in that orientation. In this case, it prints better if you flip them. I suppose someone could design in CAD for optimal print orientation, but personally, that would be too much mental geometry gymnastics. Can you also reassign the orientation afterwards? anyone?
This has been fixed!
Coming back to edit my comment. I was able to download the new files finally (size changed), and see that the geometry changed. Slicing in Cura there's still a large amount of additional seams added in this area. Slicing in Orca seems to minimize those but they do still occur. Working on a print to see how the new model works out
On the lower curved part of the large trays, OrcaSlicer generates a perfectly smooth outer perimeter first, but then it goes back and adds many tiny extrusion “dots” all around the circumference on certain layers. In preview these appear as small isolated segments on top of the perimeter, and on the print they show up as bumps/marks around the surface.
Have you run into this when slicing the large trays yourself?
Do you have a version of the inner pots that have no holes? I have been beating myself up in the slicer trying to fill them. my wife has a plant that does not need draining. Thanks
Also thank you very much my wife is super happy with these prints.
🔴 The small version is that the groove mount extends into the bottom piece, so you cannot twist off the water catchment system unless you take the whole thing off the rail. This is a BAD design. Please design it so dovetail slot extends above the top of the main planter piece rather than into the lower bowl.
@LoftedGoods
Can you post tabletop version? (without the sliding dovetail part)
Love the design! Is it possible to get a medium size?
I love this design but pretty disappointing that the Dovetail Attachment for the rail is a separate download. Everything that is shown, should be included in the download that makes this design function. You have to use one of your downloads to complete the model.
https://than.gs/m/1145814
downloaded this aswell - but where do I find the dovetail counterpart ? the part which attaches to the rail ???!
downloaded it and I cant find the dovetail part which is on the rail ? please help!!!
Hello, what is weight capacity of rail? How many planters can be hooked?
Can anyone help me? I have a Chromebook and want to print out these files but Bambu Studio is not available for Chromebook. I tried following prompts on how to set it up through linux but I keep getting errors when I am loading Bambu Studio. Is there another program that can be run through the Chromebook OS that works with an A1 mini? Thanks!
This is a nice print. Classy shape, and the large is a good size. Two issues though.
Thank you.
I think it's a very nice design and the printing took a long time but it's perfect. My only request would be to have a pot as big as the largest one in The Rail v2. Once I got used to that size, this one seems small. Would that be possible? Thank you very much.
If you're using the inner pot, do you need to use another pot?
Looking at the pictures I'm not sure, but the pot I have for my plant doesn't fit inside the inner pot.
Maybe I'm overthinking it.
Hi, I have printed everything with no issue. However, I don't seem to have the stl for the part that slides onto the dowel rods to connect the actual planter. Is that a separate download?
Yes- it is the Rail System with the link at the top of the product description for these.
Nozzel Size?
0.4mm
Question about the design of the bottom trays. What is the reason they are in a cone shape on the inside and not rounded like the outside?
That's so they can print cleanly upside down
The "Ira for the Rail" fail seems to be faulty as it cannot be opened with any slicer tool. Ultimaker and Anycubic slicer said there are no contents in the file provided
As the creator did not respond for 11 days I had to purchase another set to be able to use this set as advertised. The print is good. The support from the creator disappointing.
Hi. i cant find the dovetail rail to mount the planters on the pole??
These are just the pots. The mounting pieces are separate parts. They are in the Rail System download that can be accessed at the top of the product description for these planters.
This is a very nice looking model. I think it looks nicer than the original, but unfortunately I'm finding out that it's an insanely long print time. I'll be finishing one set and then probably not making another.
Thanks! Yes, designs that feature this fluted pattern tend to take longer to print because it's a lot of extra movement. Worth it in my opinion but I am planning on making some alternate patterns for this shape that should cut down on print time!